GUNSMOKE  "Hostage!"  12-11-72
WRITTEN BY PAUL F. EDWARDS
DIRECTED BY GUNNAR HELLSTROM
GUEST CAST
WILLIAM SMITH as JUDE BONNER
GEOFFREY LEWIS as LAFITTE
MARCO ST. JOHN as VIRGIL BONNER
JAMES CHANDLER as THE GOVERNOR
NINA ROMAN as AMY LEE
GLENN STRANGE as SAM
TED JORDAN as BURKE
WOODROW CHAMBLISS as LATHROP
HAL BAYLOR as TOKE
SANDRA KENT as MARTHA
STAFFORD REPP as SHERIFF TANNER

William Smith
William Smith as the Evil Jude Bonner
When Jude Bonner's younger brother Virgil is arrested by Marshal Dillon, tried and sentenced to hang, Jude brings his Dog Soldiers to Dodge and takes Miss Kitty to trade for his brother.  When the governor won't stay the execution, Jude brings Kitty back to Dodge beaten (and impliedly raped) by the dog soldiers.  In front of the town, he shoots her in the back.  While Miss Kitty lies hovering between life and death in Doc Adams' office, Matt hunts down Jude.  Before he leaves, Matt takes off his badge despite Doc's plea that he stay within the law.  In a one on one fight, Matt has a chance to crush Jude's head with a rock.  But his duty to the law comes first and he doesn't do it.

Great costume

William Smith with 
Geoffrey Lewis

Menacing Miss Kitty

Trying to justify his evil ways

Nothing justified this

Shooting Miss Kitty

Fighting Matt

Jude cheats

Matt doesn't
A real Barbarian Prince
The character of Jude Bonner is a William Smith classic,  strong, evil, vindictive, muscular and well costumed.  His pride requires him to rescue, and that failing, avenge his brother Virgil despite Jude's recognition that Virgil is useless, troublesome and brought his fate upon himself by continuing to party at a bar when the rest of the gang left.  The writers offer some justification for Jude's character.  He tells Kitty that his Cheyenne mother was butchered by cavalry soldiers.  As with most evil characters, he is not without cowardice.  In his one on one "unarmed" fight with Matt Dillon, he gets a knife from the 2nd in command who has been told to shoot Dillon should Jude go down in the fight.

Bonner's wicked glee

The Fight
NITEOWL REVIEW:  Jude Bonner dominates the episode.  The character could have been written for Bill and no one could have played him better.  Due to James Arness' considerable size, it may have been difficult through-out the course of the series to find villains who could offer him a realistic opponent in hand to hand combat.  However, in the final fight scene here, the contrast between the vital muscular William Smith and the [by then] older James Arness made Matt seem like an unlikely winner despite his four inch advantage in height.  [Okay, we're prejudiced.  I'm sure Arness fans would give us a fight on that comment.]  We would have liked to have seen this match up in Arness's younger years when he was one of the most physically powerful of the TV heroes.

Chick Note:  Bill looked utterly grand in this part.  He had similar facial hair and costumes, also to great effect, in Ultimate Warrior and C.C. & Company.  But this look was reserved for his villain roles.  It's really a shame that he was never cast as a hero with this kind of magnificent warrior look.

courtesy of WilliamSmith.org